Posted by Elliot Kravitz, ATP

4% Pension Income Rule

4% Pension Income Rule

What is the 4% percent rule?

The 4% rule is a general rule used to determine the amount a retiree should withdraw from a retirement account each year. This rule is intended to provide a regular income to the pensioner by maintaining an account balance that keeps the income during retirement. Experts believe that the 4% withdrawal rate is safe because withdrawals consist mainly of interest and dividends.


The 4 percent rule began to circulate after a 1998 paper titled Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate that is Sustainable, often referred to as the Trinity Study.  

Although the 4% rule was cited as a "safe retirement rate" for the use of pensions, nothing in the Trinity study supports this conclusion. Some of the convincing findings of this document include:

  • Most retirees would probably benefit from the allocation of at least 50% of the common shares.
  • Retirees who require CPC-adjusted withdrawals during retirement years must accept a substantially reduced withdrawal rate from the initial portfolio.
  • For equity portfolios, the 3% and 4% withdrawal rates are extremely conservative.

Mechanics of the 4% rule

While explaining the 4% rule, let's look at the basic principles of its application.

First, consider 4%. Apply this percentage to the initial value of the pension portfolio. If you have a $ 1,000,000 portfolio, 4% would be $ 40,000. If your portfolio is worth $ 500,000 in retirement, 4% would be $ 20,000.

This amount of 4% is the amount that can be withdrawn during the first year of retirement. It also serves as the base amount for pensions in each year of retirement.

Accounting for inflation

While some retirees who abide by the 4% rule maintain their retirement rate constant, this rule allows retirees to increase their price to keep pace with inflation. Possible ways to adjust to inflation include setting a fixed annual growth rate of 2% per annum, which is the target of Federal Reserve inflation, or adjusting withdrawals based on real inflation rates. The first method offers steady and predictable growth, while the latter approach combines income more effectively with changes in the cost of living.

When to evade the four percent rule

There are numerous scenarios in which the 4% rule may not work for a retiree. A person whose portfolio has higher risk investments than index funds and general securities should be more cautious in withdrawing money, especially in the early years of retirement. A severe or prolonged market downturn can erode the value of a high-risk investment vehicle much faster than a typical retirement portfolio.

Also, the 4% rule only works if a retiree remains faithful year after year. Violation of the one-year sporting rule of a major acquisition could have severe consequences in the future as it will reduce capital, which will directly affect the compound interest the retiree depends on for viability.

Do you have to use the rule?

Although the 4% retirement rule can provide general guidance, it is best to use more specific methods to decide how much to withdraw each year during retirement.

As a retiree, your plan must be based on other expected sources of income; the types of investments you use, the expected longevity, and the estimated tax rate each year, and many other factors. By creating a smart retirement plan, you can generate more withdrawals for some years and less during others.

The 4% rule also becomes useless when you get to the age of 70.5 because you have to withdraw money from your IRA accounts, and each year, as you get older, you have to withdraw a more substantial amount.

Well, you do not have to spend money, but you have to withdraw them from the IRA, which means paying taxes on the money. These minimum required distributions are specified by a formula and will need you to take more than 4% of the remaining amount of the account as you age.

Does it still work as a guide?

The 4% rule is not safe in an underperforming world. The achievement of the 4% rule in the United States may be a historical anomaly, and clients may view their retirement income strategies as more than merely resorting to systematic withdrawals from an unstable portfolio. Also, the 4% rule cannot be treated as a safe initial withdrawal rate in the current environment with a low-interest rate.

Elliot Kravitz, ATP
Contact Member